Papua New Guiena Intervention on West Papua at the United Nations Sessions, 2 September 2010

Author - SPMNews

September 04, 2010

Normal 0 false false false EN-US X-NONE X-NONE MicrosoftInternetExplorer4

Source:

http://itake.se/spcoldwar/index.php?showtopic=19671

Robert Guba Aisi; Permanent Representative aof Papua New Guinea to the United Nations

Whilst Papua New Guinea in the past has attempted to promote a peaceful solution in the past, to the West Papuan issue, Papua New Guinea has been most disturbed by the recent violent military-let attacks by Indonesia against West Papuan civilians of Melanesian descent. We have held good relations with Indonesia as they have been moving towards democracy and better treatment of West Papuans, but this intervention will set this back years and could possibly end ongoing negotiations if action is not taken immediately.

This military intervention is almost certainly related to ethnic tensions between the groups and must be prevented, to allow for democratic governance and for a referendum on autonomy as was recently held in East Timor.

We call upon all delegates to support efforts to bring this issue to the Human Rights Council and (should the military presence make this an international issue once more) the Security Council. Papua New Guinea sees this issue as of direct importance and believes that now is the final hope for diplomatic restitution before civil war envelopes West Papua.

This post has been edited by csj on 2 September 2010, 3:27

--------------

Papua New Guinea politely asks all delegates to entertain special consideration of the following documentation;

1. Reports of Indonesion military operations;

2. Allegations of excessive use of force during police operations;

3. Alleged extrajudicial killings during previous Indonesian operations in West Papua

The Republic of Indonesia acknowledges Papua New Guinea's statement and respects their opinion. However;

The West Papua region is and shall remain part of the Republic of Indonesia;

Indonesia is not increasing military presence within the province;

The clashes are not due to ethnicity;

At present, we have this to say;

"The Indonesian government asserts that the region voted for incorporation into the Republic of Indonesia by a referendum known as the Act of Free Choice in 1969."

Talks are ongoing whether to administer another democratic referendum within West Papua, and find a truly democratic solution.

---------------------

Robert Guba Aisi; Permanent Representative of Papua New Guinea to the United Nations

The Act of Free Choice, as revealed by declassified US documentation, has had its legitimacy called into question repeatedly, and after consultation with Vanuatu over this matter - coupled with this new round of military intervention in West Papua, leads us to strongly advocate for a withdrawal of military forces, cessation of hostilities and establishment of a proper, independent United Nations investigation of the status of Papuans within West Papua. We believe that legal investigation as proposed by Vanuatu is a logical step towards a proper legal and political settlement of the West Papua issue.

The precedence of the ruling of July 2010 affirming the legality of Kosovo's Independence is one that should be taken into direct consideration when considering the submission of this matter to the International Court of Justice.

Talks regarding West Papua must be held within an open forum, to permit free and fair negotiation that will avoid the mistakes previously made in addressing this issue. The 'Act of Free Choice' that involved less than 5% of West Papua's estimated population at the time is certainly a matter worth consideration at this time, given the situation in West Papua of immediate humanitarian concern.

------------------------

William Hague

Foreign Secretary

I agree with the Papuan delegate that a UN investigation is needed. The right to self-determination should take precedent here, the people of West Papua must be given a voice.

-------------

Murray McCully, New Zealand Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade

New Zealand government shares the British opinion that a UN investigation could be the appropriate way to defuse tensions in the area, and call both Indonesian and Papua New Guinea's Governments to prevent escalation of the crisis.

Indonesia would attend such talks.

However, we currently believe that West Papua should remain as part of the Republic of Indonesia. At present Indonesia shall not withdraw military personnel in West Papua, as we care for the innocent civilians within the province that needs our militarys' protection. Independence rallies have been getting more and more violent, and military intervention to keep the peace seems to have worked in the short term, only a long term solution needs to be met at present.

We respect the United Kingdom's and New Zealand's opinion and we thank you for voicing them to us. Indonesia would abide by any UN set regulations regarding West Papua, however, again, we believe the province should remain part of Indonesia. We feel the West Papuan people are safer as part of Indonesia.

OOC

This post has been edited by jamieperry on 3 September 2010, 17:33

QUOTE (Ivanhoe @ 3 September 2010, 13:19)

William Hague

Foreign Secretary

I agree with the Papuan delegate that a UN investigation is needed. The right to self-determination should take precedent here, the people of West Papua must be given a voice.

Ministry of foreign affairs of South Africa

Self-determination or their right to be annexed by another nation like Papua? We'll see another island like The Hispaniola in that case?

This post has been edited by Ndovlu on 3 September 2010, 20:15

--------------------

In the Soviet army it takes more courage to retreat than advance -Iosif Stalin

You will kill 10 of our men, and we will kill 1 of yours, and in the end it will be you who tire of it -Ho Chi Minh

I am the Roman Emperor, and am above grammar -Emperor Sigismund

Robert Guba Aisi; Permanent Representative of Papua New Guinea to the United Nations

Indonesian military intervention in West Papua is not a solution. Historically, has not done anything to fix the crisis; it risks only inflaming the situation and resulting in the deaths of West Papuans. It also generates a major humanitarian crisis for neighbouring ocuntries like Australia and Papau New Guinea, as we do not have the resources to deal with yet another wave of refugees fleeing across the borders.

This post has been edited by csj on 4 September 2010, 3:53

Commodore Frank Bainimarama, CF, MSD, OStJ,

Prime Minister of the Republic of Fiji,

Commander of the Republic of Fiji Military Forces

As the news reports make quite clear, the military intervention began as a response to increasingly violent protests by pro-independence groups, and so should be seen as not so tightly linked to preventing independence as is being intimated. It should instead be seen as an attempt to contain an "ever increasing violent campaign", albeit a possibly poorly planned attempt.

The current focus we believe should be directed towards containing violent demonstrations, whilst allowing peaceful legitimate protests to take place. This could possibly be done by a dual-track process of enabling local police forces and government representatives to discuss with mainstream protest groups methods of engagement and peaceful protest, whilst beginning a withdrawal of the military forces which allow those same protest groups to claim this as a military clampdown on a civilian population.

The overall drive should be towards discussions between the various factions, and a step towards normalisation of the law and order environment.

--------------------

QUOTE (Ivanhoe @ 3 September 2010, 13:19)

William Hague

Foreign Secretary

I agree with the Papuan delegate that a UN investigation is needed. The right to self-determination should take precedent here, the people of West Papua must be given a voice.

Heir Apparent Crown Prince Frederik, elder son of the monarch

I'm speaking for the UN repersentive from Denmark in this disscusion. Through I agree with the British Secretary William Hague. The people of West Papua must be given a voice. A voice through peace and not through bloodshed. I'm saying that a democratic referendum within West Papua should be held.

-----------------------

Posted via email from Papua News Posterous

Papua New Guiena Intervention on West Papua at the United Nations Sessions, 2 September 2010

Post a Comment

Is it time that Melanesian leaders allow West Papua to sit at the MSG table?

Hot Posts

Labels

Most Recent

Is it time that Melanesian leaders allow West Papua to sit at the MSG table?

ISRAEL SUPPORT FOR WEST PAPUA FREEDOM

John Ibo: Jangan Tuduh Kami Separatis

Disinyalir Jutaan Rupiah Telah Beredar Untuk Menghilangkan Nyawa Ketua DAP Forkorus Yaboisembut

Aboriginal Law must sit on top of whiteman's law, because 'our Law is the Law of this land… http://t.co/dAkbhpMYBl

Total Pageviews

Made with Love by

#buttons=(Accept !) #days=(20)

Contact form

Papua New Guiena Intervention on West Papua at the United Nations Sessions, 2 September 2010

You may like these posts

Post a Comment

#buttons=(Accept !) #days=(20)

Contact form